Today's New York Times report on how the Islamic Republic's water projects are tied to its missile program has people reading it in very different ways. I'm quoted in the story, though not about missiles. My contribution was about the price environmental activists have paid and, of course, the Laristan sheep!
A friend teased me this morning: "You spent years exposing the IRGC and Iran's water mafia, and when the New York Times finally quotes you, it's about sheep!" I guess I was the shepherd lurking in the dark all along.
We are at war, so I understand the worry about how a report like this might be read or used. The range of reactions doesn't surprise me. Some people are already arguing that it could justify attacks on dams and water infrastructure. I want to be clear about where I stand: I oppose any attack on civilian infrastructure, whoever carries it out and whatever reason is given. No report, investigation, or revelation changes that. The laws of war say so in plain language. Under Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions, Article 54 protects drinking water installations, supplies, and irrigation works. Article 56 gives dams special protection, because breaching one can release a flood that kills civilians downstream. People who had no say in what those in power did with a dam should not be the ones who drown for it.
Dam Removal? Yes. Bombing Dams? No.
A friend who has worked on water projects for several companies in Iran, Mahab Ghodss among them, had a darker joke. The best targets, he said, would be the dams that have done more harm than good, the ones that wrecked rivers and served nobody but their builders. Maybe the New York Times could publish their coordinates, and people would finally be freed from them. He was joking. The problem he was pointing at is real, though.
Taking dams out of rivers is not a radical idea. Countries do it when a dam is old, was badly conceived, or costs the river more than it gives back. Look at the Klamath River, which runs through southern Oregon and northern California. Four hydroelectric dams came out in 2023 and 2024. More than 400 miles of habitat reopened, and salmon swam back into waters they had been shut out of for over a century.
Or the Elwha in Washington State. Between 2011 and 2014, two dams were removed, opening more than 70 miles of river. Salmon returned there too, after almost a hundred years.
So dams are not forever. When one does more damage than good, it can come out, and the river starts to recover. That is nothing like bombing one. A removal takes years of study. The reservoir is drawn down slowly, and the people living downstream are warned, consulted, and protected. A bomb does it in a second, with the reservoir full and families asleep below.
A dam that should never have been built may deserve to be dismantled by local people's decision. It does not deserve to be bombed.